Use social media:

Commentary by Josh Gold - How Estonia uses Cybersecurity to Strengthen its Position in NATO

European states, especially those in close proximity to potentially threatening regional powers, tend to seek reassurance in collective arrangements often in the form of security agreements. For example, the understanding that there is safety in numbers has prompted almost all small central and eastern European states to integrate with, or to seek integration, with the Euro-Atlantic communities of the EU and NATO after the fall of communism.


Alliances are never absolutely firm. Especially for small states, the fear of abandonment by one’s allies is constant. Small states depend on NATO far more than NATO depends on them. They must therefore strive to be as valuable and indispensable to the Alliance as possible, to ensure firm NATO commitment and to allay fears of abandonment.

 
Estonia provides a good illustration of this phenomenon. Since re-independence in 1991, its foreign and security policies have been focused on guaranteeing its own security and sovereignty through NATO and EU membership. By the mid-1990s, Estonia had begun to boldly carve out a niche for itself as a forward-thinking and technologically advanced country. It eagerly embraced the internet and, as a result, Estonia has long been one of the world’s most wired states, sometimes called “e-Estonia.” A secure, digital ID for each citizen allows for the provision of almost all state services online; in the parliamentary elections in March 2019, 28% of the electorate voted online. Such innovation and moves toward a ‘digital society’ have not only brought Estonia social and economic dividends, but also play an important role in its bigger-picture national security. Estonian excellence and leadership in cybersecurity—especially after the 2007 cyberattacks—have strengthened its national security, particularly by enhancing Estonia’s position in the NATO Alliance.


What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger: 2007 as a blessing in disguise

In April 2007, violent riots erupted in the streets of Tallinn, Estonia’s capital. The rioters were members of Estonia’s significant ethnic Russian minority who, riled by Russian rhetoric and propaganda, protested against the relocation of a controversial Soviet WWII memorial to a military cemetery. In the midst of these riots, Estonia became the first victim of politically motivated cyberattacks against a sovereign state’s political and economic infrastructure. For three weeks, coordinated cyberattacks targeted Estonian government, banking, media and other sites, as well as specific routers and servers. Estonian defenders were effective and overall successful in mitigating the effects of the attacks.


Ironically, the 2007 cyberattacks have strengthened Estonia’s security situation proving, among other things, to be a turning point in Estonian efforts to increase their country’s strategic position in the NATO Alliance. Defence officials, speechwriters, and government press officers spun the unprecedented attacks into calculated narrative, seeking to frame them not as a classic Russia-versus-Estonia story, but as a new emerging global security challenge to all. Critical to this framing was a general strategy of transparency, which saw almost all information about the attacks declassified and shared with experts and analysts from across the world. Media hype and outside interest were welcomed, as the attacks were used to gain attention, sympathy, support and admiration. They were also used to demonstrate to allies that events in cyberspace are not too different from those in the physical domain; these attacks were but a preview of the threats enabled by the growing dependence the internet in increasingly digitalizing societies. The attacks exposed weaknesses and challenges facing the whole NATO Alliance, opening the door for public discussion on such attacks and highlighting the need for international cooperation in this area.


The 2007 attacks also laid the context for recognition of Estonia’s cyber defence leadership, as six other nations joined Estonia in establishing the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence (CCDCOE) in Tallinn. The Centre is essentially a military think-tank that leads the world in crafting cyber defence solutions through a multinational, interdisciplinary analysis of various cyber issues. As of 2018, the CCDCOE is responsible for identifying and coordinating education and training solutions in cyber defence for all NATO bodies across the Alliance. Today, the CCDCOE comprises 22 states, 18 NATO nations and four NATO-allied contributing participants. Many more are lined up to join, including NATO partner states Japan and Australia.


Outside of the CCDCOE, the 2007 cyberattacks and Estonia’s transparent response to them have led to major changes in NATO’s cyber defence policy. During those 2007 attacks, incumbent Estonian Defence Minister Jaak Aaviksoo said that “at present, NATO does not define cyber-attacks as a clear military action. This means that the provisions of Article V… will not automatically be extended to the attacked country.” NATO was, at the time, unprepared to adequately respond to cyber threats. The 2007 Estonian experience was a wake-up call for NATO, galvanising it into action on updating and reforming its policies to adequately address events in cyberspace as continues to do to this day.


Pending Allied approval, NATO’s first cyberspace operations doctrine is to be completed this year. According to Merle Maigre, director of the CCDCOE from 2017-2018, this doctrine is heavily influenced and shaped by work done at the CCDCOE, which takes pride in being “the custodian of NATO doctrine writing.”


Indeed, Estonia’s role in shaping NATO doctrine is a central component of its National Cyber Security Strategies over the past several years. As its 2014-2018 National Cyber Security Strategy stresses, “At the international level, the preservation of a free and secure cyberspace as well as Estonia’s central role in guiding and developing international cyber security policy in international organizations as well as like-minded communities must be ensured.” In a NATO more concerned with cyber threats, and increasingly prepared to deal with them, Estonia can have an outsized role.


Estonia’s alliance commitment mechanisms in cyber defence

A NATO that is adequately prepared to face cyber threats is better both for Estonia’s security and also for its strategic position in the Alliance. Yet the question of whether and to what extent NATO would ever go to war over a small and far-away country like Estonia is constantly in the back of Estonians’ minds. As a result, Estonia must ensure that NATO will be firmly committed to its security, and therefore must make itself as valuable and as indispensable as possible. In seeking to make NATO abandonment less likely, Estonia uses various commitment tactics in cyberspace. These tactics include: exchange, burden-sharing, normative and legal entrepreneurship and, more broadly, new ideas and innovation.


Home to NATO’s Cyber Range, Estonia and the CCDCOE host major international exercises Locked Shields, Crossed Swords, and Cyber Coalition, as well as major conferences such as CyCon – mostly at Estonia’s own expense. Estonia also hosts a wide range of other events and exercises aimed at bolstering EU and NATO states’ cyber defence positions, including EU CYBRID – a live table-top cyber defence exercise in which EU defence ministers themselves must respond to a cyber-crisis scenario. Through such events, Estonia uses the tactic of exchange; by offering important services to the Alliance, the Alliance feels more dependent on Estonia, thereby offering it stronger commitment.


Burden-sharing has been a central Estonian tactic since it joined NATO. One of Estonia’s biggest commitments to NATO is that it will not free-ride. In general, Estonia shows this by being one of just a handful of NATO states to exceed the minimum 2% of GDP spending on defence required by the Alliance. It also has a long tradition of punching above its weight vis-à-vis contributions to EU, NATO and UN military missions abroad. In cybersecurity, Estonia spends money and resources to ensure resilience of its networks, and also offers help to allies. In October 2018, then-US Defense Secretary James Mattis revealed that Estonia will become––along with the US, UK, Netherlands and Demark––one of just five NATO allies to makes its offensive cyber capabilities available to the Alliance, when needed. Other allies will surely join in lockstep, but there is some significance to being among the first.


Another area of success for Estonia, despite its small size, has been norms entrepreneurship in cyberspace, particularly regarding the application of law to cyberspace. At the forefront of legal norms in cyberspace is the Tallinn Manual (currently version 2.0). The Tallinn Manual is a non-binding, academic study on how international law applies to cyber conflicts and cyber warfare – the most authoritative and comprehensive of its kind. It is continuously developed by the CCDCOE, with input from nearly 50 states. Estonia has also positioned itself as a key player in normative work in cyberspace by the Global Commission on the Stability of Cyberspace (GCSC) and in UN deliberations, such as the UN GGE process. Through pushing for legal norms and international agreements in the UN and elsewhere, Estonia is playing an important role in the Alliance.


Finally, and more broadly, Estonia’s efforts toward ‘building a digital society’ and general path toward digitalizing its services and democratic institutions also afford the country a more secure place within NATO. NATO is an alliance based on principles of liberal democratic governance, and these principles are essential for its effectiveness, cohesion, and raison d’être. In line with NATO values, Estonia has long been a proponent of a free and open internet, as well as a champion of liberal democracy. Its society-wide experimentation and innovation with digital systems and services puts Estonia at the forefront of the nexus between technology and democracy, while intently focusing on the security threats posed by such digitalization. In this sense, Estonia is like a lab––or an incubator––that can go on to inform NATO both on security questions regarding technological advances, and on the effects of these advances on democracy and society. Insights and experiences from Estonia offer valuable models and test cases for the Alliance – and in turn ensure that Estonia remains valuable to it.


Estonia is a pawn among kings. With only 1.3 million citizens, its population and GDP are tiny. Yet thanks to its successful adoption, mastery and promotion of digital technologies and cyber excellence, little Estonia has earned a seat at the table and a voice that finds a global audience. Estonia learned this in the aftermath of the 2007 cyberattacks, discovering that in cyberspace, it is possible for tiny states to provide added value and have influence. Moreover, Estonia has found a niche in which it has a comparative advantage, and it leverages this advantage to attain a more secure position in the NATO alliance – among many other benefits. Estonia, by emphasizing cybersecurity to better its national security, shows how states can use various mechanisms to complement existing diplomatic, political, and strategic objectives.

 

 

Josh Gold, Toronto, May 2019

FOTOD - TORONTO EESTI BAPTISTI KOGUDUSE 70. JUUBELI TÄNUJUMALATEENISTUS

FOTOD - TORONTO EESTI BAPTISTI KOGUDUSE 70. JUUBELI TÄNUJUMALATEENISTUS

Pühapäeval, 25. augustil 2019.a toimus TORONTO EESTI BAPTISTI KOGUDUSE 70. JUUBELI TÄNUJUMALATEENISTUS.

BALTI APELL 40 – BALTI KETT 30

BALTI APELL 40 – BALTI KETT 30

Täna möödub kolm aastakümmet päevast, mil Hitleri ja Stalini ohvriks langenud Balti riigid üllatasid kogu maailma. Kolme okupeer...

MRP effects today

MRP effects today

Eighty years ago on August 23 Stalin and Hitler signed the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, agreeing on who would get which part of East...

Juku Gold: Estonia as an international cybersecurity leader

Juku Gold: Estonia as an international cybersecurity leader

Juku Gold is a research assistant at Citizen Lab, and a 2019 visiting fellow at The Hague Program for Cyber Norms. His bachelor’...

Üleskutse kaasmaalastele

Üleskutse kaasmaalastele

Head kaasmaalased – väärtustame meie ühiskonna- ja kultuuritegelaste mälestust!Lähiajal tähistataks...

Metsatöll tuleb jälle Torontosse

Metsatöll tuleb jälle Torontosse

  Metsatöll saabub Põhja-Ameerikasse ja Kanadasse tuurile!30 päeva jooksul antakse 24 kontser...

Learn Estonian for Both Credit and Enjoyment!

Learn Estonian for Both Credit and Enjoy…

After another successful year and with growing popularity, the University of Toronto is again off...

Learn to speak Estonian – classes for adults

Learn to speak Estonian – classes for adults

Starting Tuesday, September 10th, from 7-9:10 pm, BEGINNER and THIRD YEAR classes for adults to learn Estonian will once again t...

Kotkajärvel lõppes Põhjarada gaidide laager *Linnutee* ja Põhjakotka skautide laager *Laager 101*

Kotkajärvel lõppes Põhjarada gaidide laager *Linnutee* ja Põhjakotka skautide …

Pühapäeval, 18. augustil 2019.a Kotkajärvel lõppes Põhjarada gaidide laager ,,Linnutee“. Päev varem alustasid Põhjakotka skaudid...

Juhtkiri - Balti apell, tähelepanu ärataja 40 aastat tagasi

Juhtkiri - Balti apell, tähelepanu ärataja 40 aastat tagasi

  Üks olulisem innustaja Baltimaade pagulasi korraldama oma okupeeritud kodumaa olukorda selgitavaid poliitilisi aktsioone o...

Kuidas Kungla tantsupeol käis

Kuidas Kungla tantsupeol käis

Esimene tantsupeo proov algas meie liigijuhi Rauno Zubko sõnadega: ,,Oleme siin, et pidu ja tantsu nautida“ ja et ,,ei ole probl...

Vabamu avas Telliskivi Loomelinnaku seni avastamata ajakoridoris näituse *Balti kett 30. Üks ajalugu, kaks miljonit lugu*

Vabamu avas Telliskivi Loomelinnaku seni avastamata ajakoridoris näituse *Balt…

23. augustil 2019.a, täpselt 30 aastat pärast ajaloolist sündmust avab okupatsioonide ja vabaduse muuseum Vabamu Telliskivi Loom...

‘30th Anniversary of the Baltic Way: One History, Two Million Stories’ exhibition to open today in Telliskivi Creative City

‘30th Anniversary of the Baltic Way: One History, Two Million Stories’ exhibit…

Today, 23 August 2019, Vabamu will be opening an exhibition dedicated to the 30th anniversary of the Baltic Way in a previously ...

Ruby Sõrra tuli rannavolles Kanada meistriks

Ruby Sõrra tuli rannavolles Kanada meistriks

Kanada Rannavolle meistrivõistlustel teenis Ruby Sõrra koos mängupartneri Emma Glagau’ga kuldmedali!   Nad tulid, nad näg...

BALTI APELL, BALTI KETT KUI IME JA TULEVIKU KOOSTÖÖ MÕÕT

BALTI APELL, BALTI KETT KUI IME JA TULEVIKU KOOSTÖÖ MÕÕT

20. august 2019 läheb ajalukku Kadriorus peetud Eesti presidendi kõnega, kus vähemalt meie poliitilises ajaloos riigijuhtide tas...

Petserimaa Vabadussammas otsib toetajaid

Petserimaa Vabadussammas otsib toetajaid

Eesti Vabadussammaste taastamise kõrglaine on jäänud minevikku, aga mõnigi võlg Eesti Vabadussõjas võidelnute ja langenute ees o...

Laulvat revolutsiooni esitletakse New Yorgi publikule

Laulvat revolutsiooni esitletakse New Yorgi publikule

Eesti laulval revolutsioonil põhinev Broadway muusikal, valmimas Broadway veteran Tony Spinosa eestvedamisel, esitles hiljuti om...

Meelelahutus: Karla kalendrisaba - Sõnavara

Meelelahutus: Karla kalendrisaba - Sõnavara

Ärman juhtus jälle üle ulga aja nägu näitama. Ega ta muidu ei tule, kui on leid midagi, mille kallal iriseda. Vanad inimesed on ni...

Eesti Elu Nr. 34 - 23. august 2019

Eesti Elu Nr. 34 - 23. august 2019

Vaadake galeriid, mida huvitavat saab lugeda 23. augusti 2019.a Eesti Elu /Estonian Life paberlehest. Käesoleva nädala...


This website is supported by Estonian Life subscribers, contribute by subscribing today! :)

Üleskutse kaasmaalastele

Üleskutse kaasmaalastele

Head kaasmaalased – väärtustame meie ühiskonna- ja kultuuritegelaste mälestust!Lähiajal tähistataks...

Metsatöll tuleb jälle Torontosse

Metsatöll tuleb jälle Torontosse

  Metsatöll saabub Põhja-Ameerikasse ja Kanadasse tuurile!30 päeva jooksul antakse 24 kontser...

Learn Estonian for Both Credit and Enjoyment!

Learn Estonian for Both Credit and Enjoy…

After another successful year and with growing popularity, the University of Toronto is again off...

Learn to speak Estonian – classes for adults

Learn to speak Estonian – classes for ad…

Starting Tuesday, September 10th, from 7-9:10 pm, BEGINNER and THIRD YEAR classes for adults to l...

Tere / Hello / Bonjour Golfers!

Tere / Hello / Bonjour Golfers!

  DUE TO UNFORESEEN CIRCUMSTANCES, the 14th Annual MES Golf Tournament has been rescheduled f...

Üleilmne eesti keele nädal ehk eesti keele “Teeme ära!”

Üleilmne eesti keele nädal ehk eesti kee…

PRESSITEADE08.03.19Eesti Instituut Eesti Instituut kutsub ühe nädala jooksul, 23.-29. septembril 20...

Algab 12. rahvusvaheline Hiite fotovõistlus

Algab 12. rahvusvaheline Hiite fotovõist…

Hiite Maja pressiteade 6.06.2019   Algab rahvusvaheline Hiite kuvavõistlus, kuhu oodataks...

Eesti Elu Nr. 34 - 23. august 2019

Eesti Elu Nr. 34 - 23. august 2019

Vaadake galeriid, mida huvitavat saab lugeda 23. augusti 2019.a Eesti Elu /Estonian Life pab...

Marcus Kolga: Canada and the threat of European populism

Marcus Kolga: Canada and the threat of E…

Modern European populism is a predatory scheme that is rooted in the raw exploitation of inequali...

Toomas Hendrik Ilves: Me seisame kahe riigi väraval

Toomas Hendrik Ilves: Me seisame kahe ri…

Saatuse, kurjuse ja ka omaenda vigade tõttu tähistame kahte iseseisvuspäeva. Üks, 24. veebruar on...

FOTOD - "Warriors' Day Parade" Canadian National Exhibition'is 2019

FOTOD - "Warriors' Day Parade"…

Laupäeval, 17. augustil 2019.a toimus Canadian National Exhibition'is 98. "Warriors' Day Parade"....

PHOTO GALLERY - Port Credit Buskerfest Fire Show 2019

PHOTO GALLERY - Port Credit Buskerfest F…

Friday August 16, 2019 featuring Incendia Modus from Quebec and Zap Circus from Australia.

Black Ribbon Day - Commemoration in Ottawa

Black Ribbon Day - Commemoration in Otta…

Press Release  August 22, 2019Wellington Building, 180 Wellington Street, Room 430 Programm...

SUUR FOTOGALERII - 52. Metsaülikooli nädala teise poole ülevaade

SUUR FOTOGALERII - 52. Metsaülikooli näd…

Metsaülikool jätkus pärast teisipäeva õhtul toimunud vägevat Retro Rokk pidu kolmapäeval ajakirja...

Gaidlipkond Põhjarada laagris Kotkajärvel 2019

Gaidlipkond Põhjarada laagris Kotkajärve…

  Pühapäeval, 11. augustil 2019.a avati Kotkajärvel lipkonna Põhjarada esimene lipkonnalaager...

Ene Mihkelsoni saladus

Ene Mihkelsoni saladus

Vähe on saladusi, mis igavesti saladuseks jäävad. Mis jäävad, nende puhul hakatakse harilikult spek...

Pahupidi pööratud plahvatus

Pahupidi pööratud plahvatus

  Eks me kõik ole kuulnud, kuidas kuritegevus aina kasvab ja areneb, mõnel pool mõnel ajal la...

Uudiseid Petserimaalt

Uudiseid Petserimaalt

  Juurdunud tava kohaselt tähistavad Petserimaa eestlased juba aastaid lõikuskuu esimesel lau...

Perceptions of a newcomer to Kotkajärve Metsaülikool

Perceptions of a newcomer to Kotkajärve …

Sirje Kiin, my wife, has been attending Kotkajärve for quite a few years, so I have heard many good...

Vancouver folkdance group "Kilplased" performed at the recent Song and Dance Festival in Tallinn

Vancouver folkdance group "Kilplase…

Eight pairs of dancers from the Vancouver folkdance group "Kilplased" performed at the recent Son...

Learn Estonian for Both Credit and Enjoyment!

Learn Estonian for Both Credit and Enjoy…

After another successful year and with growing popularity, the University of Toronto is again off...

Juhtkiri - Kes on õige eestlane?

Juhtkiri - Kes on õige eestlane?

Kas see on õige eestlane, kes arvab, et sinine, must ja valge on kõige lahedamad värvid, ükskõik,...

Matthias Kask võistles edukalt Eesti meistrivõistlustel

Matthias Kask võistles edukalt Eesti mei…

Torontost pärit Matthias Uwe Kask võitis Kadriorus peetud hiljutistel Eesti meistrivõistlustel te...

MRP collusion between the Soviets and Nazis, sinister facts the Kremlin cannot reveal

MRP collusion between the Soviets and Na…

It’s been 80 years since the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact of August 23, 1939 was signed between Nazi G...

Väliseesti näituste festival sai Eestis hoo sisse

Väliseesti näituste festival sai Eestis …

2019. a suvel toimunud ESTO festival, juubelilaulupidu ning eesseisev suurpõgenemise 75. aastapäe...

Meelelahutus: Karla kalendrisaba - Mis sa mõtled vai arvad

Meelelahutus: Karla kalendrisaba - Mis s…

Nende kahe sõnaga on inimestel alati äda old. Ei tea, kumba kasutada, noh. Tihtipeale juhtub, et va...

KUNSTNIK KAI KALJO RESIDEERUB 2019. AASTA OKTOOBRIS HAMILTONI ARTS COUNCIL’I KUNSTNIKE VAHETUSPROGRAMMI RAAMES COTTON FACTORY’S

KUNSTNIK KAI KALJO RESIDEERUB 2019. AAST…

Tallinn, EESTI – 10 Juuli 2019 – Rahvusvaheliselt tuntud video- ja visuaalkunstnik Kai Kaljo ...

Kaugel läänes

Kaugel läänes

Eestlaste üritused olid tõepoolest globaalsed möödunud suvel. Seda nimetust kindlustas LEP või (P...

Eesti Elu Nr. 33 - 16. august 2019

Eesti Elu Nr. 33 - 16. august 2019

Vaadake galeriid, mida huvitavat saab lugeda 16. augusti 2019.a Eesti Elu /Estonian Life pab...

FOTOD - Jõekääru Kalevi VÕRKPALLILAAGER 2019

FOTOD - Jõekääru Kalevi VÕRKPALLILAAGER …

Laupäevast, 3. augustist kuni laupäeva,  10. augustini 2019.a toimub Udoras,  Jõek...

FOTOD - Kotkajärvel algas 52. Metsaülikool

FOTOD - Kotkajärvel algas 52. Metsaüliko…

Laupäeval, 3. augustil 2019.a algas Kotkajärvel järjekorras juba 52. Metsaülikool. Kuna seekordne...

BaltHerNeti IX suvekool toimus ESTO hõlmas

BaltHerNeti IX suvekool toimus ESTO hõlm…

Kuna tänavu suvel toimus Soomes ja Eestis ESTO festival, sai väliseesti kultuuripärandiga tegelev...

Kallihinnalised Tartu Peetri kiriku armulauakarikad on jõudnud tagasi Eestisse

Kallihinnalised Tartu Peetri kiriku armu…

Ja ta võttis karika, tänas ja andis neile, ja nad kõik jõid sellest. Mk 14:23   1944.a. s...

Metsatöll tuleb jälle Torontosse

Metsatöll tuleb jälle Torontosse

  Metsatöll saabub Põhja-Ameerikasse ja Kanadasse tuurile!30 päeva jooksul antakse 24 kontser...

Paar tähelepanekut CIOR aastakongressilt

Paar tähelepanekut CIOR aastakongressilt

Käib Tallinnas sel nädalal CIOR aastakongress. Isiklikult oli muude tegemiste vahel aega osaleda ...

ESTO Youth Programme Brought Together Over 60 Youth From 25 Countries JUKU GOLD

ESTO Youth Programme Brought Together Ov…

From June 27 to July 3, Estonians from across the world came together to celebrate their Estonian...

Estonian Centre Project Update - Estonia's Ministry of Culture held a well-attended conference in Tallinn on July 3, 2019 within esto2019 to discuss how to strengthen Estonia's footprint around the world.

Estonian Centre Project Update - Estonia…

  Estonia's Ministry of Culture held a well-attended conference in Tallinn on July 3, 2019 ...

FOTOD - Jõekääru suvekodu 2019 lõpunädal

FOTOD - Jõekääru suvekodu 2019 lõpunädal

Nagu öeldakse, siis kolm on kohtu seadus ja täpselt nii meil ka läks. Kolm imeliselt hästi kordal...

Pärnus peeti rahvusvahelise õiguse suveülikooli

Pärnus peeti rahvusvahelise õiguse suveü…

  Eesti Ameerika Fondi pressiteade   Martensi nimeline rahvusvahelise õiguse suveüliko...

ÄPARDUNUKS POSITUD VÄLISPOLIITIKA

ÄPARDUNUKS POSITUD VÄLISPOLIITIKA

Valitsuse pressikonverentsil 25.07.19 ütles peaminis-ter Jüri Ratas:„Kui räägime Eesti välispolii...

EESTI HETKED - Viksid triksid

EESTI HETKED - Viksid triksid

Kui palju kordi olen valesti öelnud poistele (nt hundudele nende juhina) või isegi mehele, et „Võ...

Tere / Hello / Bonjour Golfers!

Tere / Hello / Bonjour Golfers!

  DUE TO UNFORESEEN CIRCUMSTANCES, the 14th Annual MES Golf Tournament has been rescheduled f...

Juhtkiri - ,,Me hoiame nõnda ühte….

Juhtkiri - ,,Me hoiame nõnda ühte….

….ja läheme läbi mere, mis tõuseb me vastu tige,“ ütleb Paul-Eerik Rummo. Sama sõnum kostis meile...

Estonian Centre Project Update - Estonia's Ministry of Culture held a well-attended conference in Tallinn on July 3, 2019 within esto2019 to discuss how to strengthen Estonia's footprint around the world.

Estonian Centre Project Update - Estonia's Ministry of Culture held a well-att…

  Estonia's Ministry of Culture held a well-attended conference in Tallinn on July 3, 2019 within esto2019 to discuss how ...

Eesti Keskuse Projekti Teated - Eesti Maja juhatuse liikme ja International Estonian Centre vabatahtliku abilise Eric Sehri sõnavõtt 7. juunil toimunud kokkusaamisel

Eesti Keskuse Projekti Teated - Eesti Maja juhatuse liikme ja International Es…

Mul on hea meel tervitada kõiki järjekordsel kogukonna teavituskoosolekul. Meil on põhjust põnevusega oodata meie külalise, No...

Eesti Keskuse Projekti Teated - Ottawa ja Montreali eestlased toetavad Eesti Keskuse projekti

Eesti Keskuse Projekti Teated - Ottawa ja Montreali eestlased toetavad Eesti K…

2. juunil said Ottawa ja Montreali Eesti Seltsid kokku tulevases Eesti saatkonna hoones Ottawas, tähistamaks Eesti lipu 135. a...

Estonian Centre Project Update - Remarks by Eric Sehr, Estonian House Board Member and International Estonian Centre Volunteer, at the June 7 Community Engagement Session

Estonian Centre Project Update - Remarks by Eric Sehr, Estonian House Board Me…

One of the reasons we should be excited is that the square we are developing goes to the very heart of building a community. I...

FOTOD - TORONTO EESTI BAPTISTI KOGUDUSE 70. JUUBELI TÄNUJUMALATEENISTUS

FOTOD - TORONTO EESTI BAPTISTI KOGUDUSE …

Pühapäeval, 25. augustil 2019.a toimus TORONTO EESTI BAPTISTI KOGUDUSE 70. JUUBELI TÄNUJUMALATEEN...

BALTI APELL 40 – BALTI KETT 30

BALTI APELL 40 – BALTI KETT 30

Täna möödub kolm aastakümmet päevast, mil Hitleri ja Stalini ohvriks langenud Balti riigid üllata...

Learn to speak Estonian – classes for adults

Learn to speak Estonian – classes for ad…

Starting Tuesday, September 10th, from 7-9:10 pm, BEGINNER and THIRD YEAR classes for adults to l...

Kotkajärvel lõppes Põhjarada gaidide laager *Linnutee* ja Põhjakotka skautide laager *Laager 101*

Kotkajärvel lõppes Põhjarada gaidide laa…

Pühapäeval, 18. augustil 2019.a Kotkajärvel lõppes Põhjarada gaidide laager ,,Linnutee“. Päev var...

Kuidas Kungla tantsupeol käis

Kuidas Kungla tantsupeol käis

Esimene tantsupeo proov algas meie liigijuhi Rauno Zubko sõnadega: ,,Oleme siin, et pidu ja tants...

Ruby Sõrra tuli rannavolles Kanada meistriks

Ruby Sõrra tuli rannavolles Kanada meist…

Kanada Rannavolle meistrivõistlustel teenis Ruby Sõrra koos mängupartneri Emma Glagau’ga kuldmeda...

Petserimaa Vabadussammas otsib toetajaid

Petserimaa Vabadussammas otsib toetajaid

Eesti Vabadussammaste taastamise kõrglaine on jäänud minevikku, aga mõnigi võlg Eesti Vabadussõja...

FOTOD - "Warriors' Day Parade" Canadian National Exhibition'is 2019

FOTOD - "Warriors' Day Parade"…

Laupäeval, 17. augustil 2019.a toimus Canadian National Exhibition'is 98. "Warriors' Day Parade"....

PHOTO GALLERY - Port Credit Buskerfest Fire Show 2019

PHOTO GALLERY - Port Credit Buskerfest F…

Friday August 16, 2019 featuring Incendia Modus from Quebec and Zap Circus from Australia.

Black Ribbon Day - Commemoration in Ottawa

Black Ribbon Day - Commemoration in Otta…

Press Release  August 22, 2019Wellington Building, 180 Wellington Street, Room 430 Programm...

SUUR FOTOGALERII - 52. Metsaülikooli nädala teise poole ülevaade

SUUR FOTOGALERII - 52. Metsaülikooli näd…

Metsaülikool jätkus pärast teisipäeva õhtul toimunud vägevat Retro Rokk pidu kolmapäeval ajakirja...

Gaidlipkond Põhjarada laagris Kotkajärvel 2019

Gaidlipkond Põhjarada laagris Kotkajärve…

  Pühapäeval, 11. augustil 2019.a avati Kotkajärvel lipkonna Põhjarada esimene lipkonnalaager...

Pahupidi pööratud plahvatus

Pahupidi pööratud plahvatus

  Eks me kõik ole kuulnud, kuidas kuritegevus aina kasvab ja areneb, mõnel pool mõnel ajal la...

Perceptions of a newcomer to Kotkajärve Metsaülikool

Perceptions of a newcomer to Kotkajärve …

Sirje Kiin, my wife, has been attending Kotkajärve for quite a few years, so I have heard many good...

Vancouver folkdance group "Kilplased" performed at the recent Song and Dance Festival in Tallinn

Vancouver folkdance group "Kilplase…

Eight pairs of dancers from the Vancouver folkdance group "Kilplased" performed at the recent Son...

Matthias Kask võistles edukalt Eesti meistrivõistlustel

Matthias Kask võistles edukalt Eesti mei…

Torontost pärit Matthias Uwe Kask võitis Kadriorus peetud hiljutistel Eesti meistrivõistlustel te...

Kaugel läänes

Kaugel läänes

Eestlaste üritused olid tõepoolest globaalsed möödunud suvel. Seda nimetust kindlustas LEP või (P...

FOTOD - Jõekääru Kalevi VÕRKPALLILAAGER 2019

FOTOD - Jõekääru Kalevi VÕRKPALLILAAGER …

Laupäevast, 3. augustist kuni laupäeva,  10. augustini 2019.a toimub Udoras,  Jõek...

Read more (click on the following topic): Life - Opinion

MRP effects today

MRP effects today

Eighty years ago on August 23 Stalin and Hitler signed the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, agre...

Juku Gold: Estonia as an international cybersecurity leader

Juku Gold: Estonia as an international c…

Juku Gold is a research assistant at Citizen Lab, and a 2019 visiting fellow at The Hagu...

Juhtkiri - Balti apell, tähelepanu ärataja 40 aastat tagasi

Juhtkiri - Balti apell, tähelepanu ärata…

  Üks olulisem innustaja Baltimaade pagulasi korraldama oma okupeeritud kodumaa oluk...

BALTI APELL, BALTI KETT KUI IME JA TULEVIKU KOOSTÖÖ MÕÕT

BALTI APELL, BALTI KETT KUI IME JA TULEV…

20. august 2019 läheb ajalukku Kadriorus peetud Eesti presidendi kõnega, kus vähemalt me...

Marcus Kolga: Canada and the threat of European populism

Marcus Kolga: Canada and the threat of E…

Modern European populism is a predatory scheme that is rooted in the raw exploitation of...

Toomas Hendrik Ilves: Me seisame kahe riigi väraval

Toomas Hendrik Ilves: Me seisame kahe ri…

Saatuse, kurjuse ja ka omaenda vigade tõttu tähistame kahte iseseisvuspäeva. Üks, 24. ve...

Juhtkiri - Kes on õige eestlane?

Juhtkiri - Kes on õige eestlane?

Kas see on õige eestlane, kes arvab, et sinine, must ja valge on kõige lahedamad värvid,...

MRP collusion between the Soviets and Nazis, sinister facts the Kremlin cannot reveal

MRP collusion between the Soviets and Na…

It’s been 80 years since the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact of August 23, 1939 was signed betwe...

ÄPARDUNUKS POSITUD VÄLISPOLIITIKA

ÄPARDUNUKS POSITUD VÄLISPOLIITIKA

Valitsuse pressikonverentsil 25.07.19 ütles peaminis-ter Jüri Ratas:„Kui räägime Eesti v...

Käesolev veebileht on Eesti Elu paberlehe tellijate toetatud, toeta sinagi ja telli leht juba täna:)

 

Vabamu avas Telliskivi Loomelinnaku seni avastamata ajakoridoris näituse *Balti kett 30. Üks ajalugu, kaks miljonit lugu*

Vabamu avas Telliskivi Loomelinnaku seni…

23. augustil 2019.a, täpselt 30 aastat pärast ajaloolist sündmust avab okupatsioonide ja...

‘30th Anniversary of the Baltic Way: One History, Two Million Stories’ exhibition to open today in Telliskivi Creative City

‘30th Anniversary of the Baltic Way: One…

Today, 23 August 2019, Vabamu will be opening an exhibition dedicated to the 30th annive...

Laulvat revolutsiooni esitletakse New Yorgi publikule

Laulvat revolutsiooni esitletakse New Yo…

Eesti laulval revolutsioonil põhinev Broadway muusikal, valmimas Broadway veteran Tony S...

Ene Mihkelsoni saladus

Ene Mihkelsoni saladus

Vähe on saladusi, mis igavesti saladuseks jäävad. Mis jäävad, nende puhul hakatakse harili...

Uudiseid Petserimaalt

Uudiseid Petserimaalt

  Juurdunud tava kohaselt tähistavad Petserimaa eestlased juba aastaid lõikuskuu esi...

Learn Estonian for Both Credit and Enjoyment!

Learn Estonian for Both Credit and Enjoy…

After another successful year and with growing popularity, the University of Toronto is ...

Väliseesti näituste festival sai Eestis hoo sisse

Väliseesti näituste festival sai Eestis …

2019. a suvel toimunud ESTO festival, juubelilaulupidu ning eesseisev suurpõgenemise 75....

KUNSTNIK KAI KALJO RESIDEERUB 2019. AASTA OKTOOBRIS HAMILTONI ARTS COUNCIL’I KUNSTNIKE VAHETUSPROGRAMMI RAAMES COTTON FACTORY’S

KUNSTNIK KAI KALJO RESIDEERUB 2019. AAST…

Tallinn, EESTI – 10 Juuli 2019 – Rahvusvaheliselt tuntud video- ja visuaalkunstnik K...

BaltHerNeti IX suvekool toimus ESTO hõlmas

BaltHerNeti IX suvekool toimus ESTO hõlm…

Kuna tänavu suvel toimus Soomes ja Eestis ESTO festival, sai väliseesti kultuuripärandig...


Estonian Life

Subscription

  
Subscribe to Estonian Life
and support the Estonian community
newspaper in Canada!


Subscriptions in Canada:

Annual - $150
Semi-annual - $80
Quarter-year - $43
Click here for other subscription options!

Payment options:
• By cash or cheque
at the Estonian Life office
Fund transfer
to Estonian Life account
at Estonian Credit Union or via 
their phone
(Phone# 416-465-4659)
• Cheque or money order
written out to 
Estonian Life
Interac e-Transfer® to
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. 
PayPal/Credit Card

 
Report an event,
send your story or tip!

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
 

 Where to buy
Estonian Life
single copies
in Toronto:

 

  • Estonian Life office (3 Madison Ave. / 310 Bloor St. W.)
  • Estonian House office (958 Broadview Ave)
  • Leaside Pharmacy (close to Suomi Koti, 795 Eglinton Ave. E.)

  

Subscribe now!

 

 
Report an event,
send your story or tip!

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
 

Portland - LEP 2019

Eesti Elu - 3 Madison Ave., Toronto, ON M5R 2S2 - Ajalehe Tellimine - Kuulutuste tellimine - Tel: 416-733-4550 - Fax: 416-733-0944 - e-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. ©2012 - 2018 Eesti Elu. All rights reserved.
Made by CyberQA & Confirmo