Foreign interference in Canadian elections has been a major concern since Russian entities interfered in the 2016 US presidential campaign. Before and during the 2019 Canadian federal election, authorities warned that foreign governments would attempt to influence the federal election process. While some major disinformation operations have taken place—primarily targeting Justin Trudeau with fabricated stories about alleged misconduct—the true origins of these efforts are not yet known.
Russian disinformation campaigns have targeted both Conservative and Liberal politicians since 2014, but a major coordinated attack like the one seen in the 2016 US election has not yet been detected. However, Chinese influence operations and disinformation targeting Canadian Chinese communities has been a glaring concern.
In addition to engaging in disinformation operations, Canadian authorities have warned that foreign governments may also try to influence domestic politics by “by attending nomination meetings to help select candidates favorable to their causes.”
Russian Proxies
Russian influence and disinformation operations in Canada became active immediately following the Russian annexation of Crimea in 2014. Since then, Canadian pro-Kremlin groups have pushed narratives that are consistent with those promoted by the Putin regime, including the conspiracy theory that Canada “is populated by descendants of Nazis who now exert outsized political power…” These organizations have also tried to affect Canadian legislation in the past—including Canadian Magnitsky legislation—and to discredit Canada’s leadership of NATO’s Enhanced Forward Presence in Latvia and training missions in Ukraine.
During the 2015 Canadian federal election, the Russian Canadian Congress published a letter that stated that the “horrible human rights violations conducted by Ukrainian government and the radical ultra-nationalist organizations… enjoy full support from the current Conservative government.”
However, these groups have remained relatively silent on social media during the election period. Members of pro-Putin Canadian social media groups have posted support for the far-right populist People’s Party of Canada, led by former Conservative cabinet minister, Maxim Bernier. And known pro-Kremlin trolls and sock puppets have amplified misinformation primarily targeting Justin Trudeau and Liberal candidates.
Among the positions promoted by pro-Kremlin accounts are Bernier’s anti-immigration policies and the perception that the People’s Party is anti-LGBTQ. While all three mainstream parties, the New Democratic Party, Liberals, and Conservatives, have each expressed support for expanding Magnitsky sanctions and for Ukrainian independence and sovereignty over Crimea. The People’s Party has not. Instead, their election platform stated that, it will not allow Canada to “get involved in foreign conflicts unless we have a compelling strategic interest in doing so.”
Chinese Influence
For several years Chinese government influence has been a major concern in electoral districts around Toronto and Vancouver, which have large concentrations of Chinese voters. Those same suburban ridings are the primary battlegrounds in the 2019 election, and the results of those local elections will help shape the overall outcome of the federal election.
The mixture of Chinese government influence, possible ties to campaign financing, and targeted messaging, has created a toxic political environment that has threatened to undermine local and national trust in the Canadian democratic process. Their influence on local political campaigns can be seen in their promotion of candidates from both leading political parties who adopt positions favorable to China.
In 2015, Toronto-area member of the Ontario Provincial Parliament, and Minister of Citizenship, Immigration and International Trade, Michael Chan, was identified in an explosive Globe and Mail article about Chinese regime influence in Canadian politics. The report claimed that CSIS, Canada’s intelligence agency, briefed Ontario officials about Chan, who, according to them, “had developed too close a relationship with China’s consulate in Toronto, raising fears the minister was susceptible to interference from Beijing that could put Canada’s national interests at risk.”
Chinese Communist Party-funded (CCP) junkets are also a key channel for influencing Canadian politicians. Since 2006, the CCP has funded nearly forty junkets for federal ministers of parliament (MPs) and Senators. These trips expose parliamentarians to Chinese propaganda and influence.
Notably, the former federal Liberal cabinet minister, John McCallum—whose seat was in the same federal riding as Chan’s provincial one—took trips funded by China and pro-Beijing business groups, valued at 73,300 dollars, before he became Canada’s ambassador to China from 2017 until 2019. He resigned after publicly wading into the extradition case of Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou. In June of this year, Conservative leader Andrew Scheer accused McCallum of inviting Chinese interference in the October federal election.
Most recently, Conservative MP, Bob Saroya—whose electoral district north of Toronto is next to the one held by McCallum, and has the highest concentration of Chinese voters—was identified by the Globe and Mail for having taken a CCP-funded junket to China in 2018.
The Chinese community in Canada was targeted by political ads on the Chinese social media platform WeChat in violation of Canadian campaign advertising laws. Many of the ads featured false information specifically targeting the community, which is particularly sensitive to illegal immigration, crime, and drug use issues. Saroya’s campaign reportedly utilized false information in his campaign about ‘fake refugees’ being allowed to illegally enter Canada in his campaign literature. Another Conservative-branded ad urged viewers to vote for the party and made the false claim that Justin Trudeau would legalize hard drugs if elected. The message on the ad stated that “Only Andrew Scheer’s Conservatives will stop Trudeau’s hard drug legalization plan and keep our kids safe.” The Conservative Party placed similar ads with the same messaging on Facebook targeting Chinese voters.
It should be noted that all three main political parties signed the Transatlantic Commission for Election Integrity’s pledge to not engage in the use of mis- or disinformation.
Conclusion
While the overall outcome of the 2019 Canadian federal election was not the result of foreign influence, it is likely that it did have an effect on local and federal debates and outcomes, which was amplified by domestic political engagement in the use of misinformation and disinformation. In the future we should expect more attempts to use raw and negative propaganda, including misinformation and disinformation by domestic actors both independently and in concert with malign foreign actors in Canada.
Marcus Kolga, Toronto
Read original article from here: Trolling Trudeau: Fears of Foreign Interference in Canada
Kolmapäeval, 24. veebruaril 2021.a heisati taas Toronto raekoja poodiumil sini-must-valge lipp et tähistada Eesti Vabariigi 1...
Kolmapäeval, 24. veebruaril 2021.a heisati Eesti Vabariigi 103. aastapäeva auks sini-must-valged lipud ka Torontos Eesti Maja, Eha...
Kolmapäeval, 24. veebruaril 2021.a värvusid Kanadas mitmed tuntud maamärgid EV103 sünnipäeva auks sini-must-valgeks. Trikoloori vä...
Kolmapäeval, 24. veebruaril 2021.a lehvis Hamiltoni raekoja poodiumil Hamiltoni Eesti Seltsi korraldusel sini-must-valge lipp tähi...
Igal aastal on Eestis aasta lind ja loom. Isegi aasta puu ja seen! 2021 Eesti aasta lind on K...
Wednesday, March 10th, 2021 at 7:00 PMAdmission begins at 6:00 PMTo be held electronically via Zoom...
Kolmapäeval, 10. märtsil 2021 kell 19.00Osalejad võivad liituda alates kell 18.00Toimub elektroonil...
''Enjoy the first online concert in Estonian Music Week's series ''Memories of Home'' featuring Toronto's own Tiina Kiik and Tuuli...
Kauni traditsioonina lehvib igal aastal 24. veebruaril Eesti Vabariigi aastapäeva auks Eesti sini-must-valge lipp Ottawa linnavali...
Kes meist mäletab Metro rahvusvahelist Karavani? See oli siis, kui eestlased hakkasid kohe kaasa lööma ühele nädalapikkusele festi...
Hearing things about Estonia in English language films, TV shows, music, and books is an infrequent thing. Have you ever noticed t...
Connor Olev O'Brien is CEO of O’Shares ETF Investments, as well as Stanton Asset Management. He has over 25 years of global invest...
At the Art Gallery of Nova Scotia, in Halifax, to visit the transplanted house and paintings of Canadian folk artist Maud Lewis, y...
Helmi Hess on üks kahest Kanada Eesti teaduskraadi üliõpilasest, kes sai 2020. aasta ESK stipendiumi, mida rahastab Vilma ja Heinr...
Kui Raivo ja Anne-Mari Remmel mõtlevad järgmise põlvkonna eestlastele, siis näevad nad tulevikus eredalt põlevat leeki. Et ...
Pühapäev on saanud oma nimetuse ladinakeelsest antiphonist.Algselt missa liturgia algusosas vaimuliku ja koori gregooriuse lauluna...
Toronto eesti kooli tunnis on päev enne Eesti Vabariigi sünnipäeva olulisteks sõnadeks rahvuslind, rahvuslill, rahvuspuu ja teised...
Briti Kolumbias, Vancouveri lähedal White Rock’is elav Annaliisa Kapp on holistiline toitumisnõustaja ja toitumisterapeut, kelle e...
24. veebruaril kutsus Tallinna Linna/muuseum tähistama Eesti Vaba/riigi 103. aasta/päeva veebi/keskkonnas ning jalutus/käiguga aja...
Eesti Elu Nr. 8 - 26. veebruar 2021 DIGILEHT
Vaata eelnevaid Eesti Elu nädalalehe numbreid siin:
- Eesti Elu Nr. 7 - 19. veebruar 2021 - DIGILEHT
- Eesti Elu Nr. 6 - 12. veebruar 2021 - DIGILEHT
- Eesti Elu Nr. 5 - 5. veebruar 2021 - DIGILEHT
Kõik numbrid koos sisukorraga: www.issuu.com/estonianlife
Oled juba paberlehe tellija ja soovid tasuta ligipääsu digilehele? Tekkis küsimus või kommentaar? Kirjuta meile digi@eestielu.ca!
NB. Palun lisa digi@eestielu.ca oma e-maili aadressi raamatusse (safe senders list/address book/primary inbox), et meie e-kirjad tuleksid kohale. Palun anna märku, kui oled digilehe tellinud ja kättesaamisega on tekkinud raskusi.
Please add us to your address book/safe senders list/primary inbox to make sure the email with access code does not go to junk mail or bounce back. Please reach out if you are having troubles receiving our emails on Fridays.
Igal aastal on Eestis aasta lind ja loom. Isegi aasta puu ja seen! 2021 Eesti aasta lind on K...
Wednesday, March 10th, 2021 at 7:00 PMAdmission begins at 6:00 PMTo be held electronically via Zoom...
Kolmapäeval, 10. märtsil 2021 kell 19.00Osalejad võivad liituda alates kell 18.00Toimub elektroonil...
2020. aastal korraldas Eesti Kunstnike Koondis Torontos (EKKT) oma liikmetele akvarelli-õpitoa, mid...
Välismaal elavad eesti päritolu noored on oodatud ka sel aastal Eestisse eesti keele ja kultuuri la...
Väliseesti Muuseum (VEMU) koostöös Eesti Kirjanike Liidu ja Eesti Kirjanduse Teabekeskusega kuuluta...
Väliseesti Muuseum Torontos ja Eesti Kirjandusmuuseum Tartus kuulutavad alates 1. detsembrist ...
Kalevipoeg (Son of Kalev) is an Estonian epic poem written by Friedrich Reinhold Kreutzwald in 1853...
24. veebruaril kutsus Tallinna Linna/muuseum tähistama Eesti Vaba/riigi 103. aasta/päeva veebi/kesk...
Mida ütleks vanaema, kui näeks pirukate valikus sõna KIMCHI? Arvan, et ta ütles: „Aga see on ju hap...
Armastus käib kõhu kaudu. Rahvatarkus. Luuletaja Hando Runnel lisas lausele vallatult, „leiaks ainu...
Juhul, kui tekkiski kahtlus, eestlased on tõesti loov rahvas. Ajal, mil Covidi tõttu olid kõik oma ...
Estonia’s recently published annual Foreign Intelligence Service report focuses on the aggressive a...
Vaadake, mida huvitavat saab lugeda 26. veebruari 2021.a Eesti Elu /Estonian Life nädalalehest.&n...
Niagara Falls – Eestlaste Kesknõukogu Kanadas (EKN) on organiseerinud Niagara kose rahvusvärvidegak...
The Estonian Central Council in Canada has organized the lighting of Niagara Falls in blue, black a...
Vabariigi aastapäev liidab meid rõõmus ja mures. Ta liidab meid ühise mineviku meenutustega ja tule...
Eestlaste Kesknõukogu Kanadas nimel soovin kõigile eestlastele Kanadas ja mujal ning meie toetajate...
Meenutame Laupäeval, 24. veebruaril 2018.a Torontos Nathan Phillips Square’il EV100 auks toimunud p...
To our dear friends in the Estonian Community,Palju õnne sünnipäevaks, Eesti!Best wishes on Estonia...
Eestlased läbi aja on olnud ohustatud liik. Neid on vähe ja neid on raske leida (samas on nad igas ...
Six years after Russian opposition leader Boris Nemtsov was assassinated, Ottawa has made scant use...
The world has followed closely the attempted assassination via poisoning, recent arrest, and now co...
Hiina valitsuse rahastatud suured taristuprojektid võivad tunduda ligitõmbavad, kuid nendega kaasne...
The allure of doing business with one of the world’s largest economies is massive. Chinese financin...
EV 103.a. virtuaalne tähistamine pühapäeval, 21. veebruaril Käesoleval aastal meie ei saa koos heis...
Talvel on linde lihtsam fotodele tabada kuna puud on raagus ja lehti ei ole millede varju linnud pe...
Nii mõnigi meist on viimasel aastal mitte arvutiekraani taha olnud liimitud, vaid neid leitud tunde...
In 1962, the Estonian town of Põltsamaa, in Jõgeva county, produced the first metal tubes of space ...
Tehnikateaduste doktor, optilise elektroonika professor emeritus ENDEL UIGA. Teadlane, leiutaj...
Praegusel pandeemia ajal tasub meeles pidada rahvatarkust ,,elu on võitlus, mida võitlema peab“, et...
It's a commonly referenced fact that the Estonian language belongs to a different language family; ...
Elame tõepoolest kummalistel aegadel, mil paistab valitsevat kui mitte ohmudekari, siis tulevikule ...
Estonia kontserdisaalis oli 12. veebruaril kultuurilooliselt äärmiselt põnev kontsert, mida dirigee...
Kaili Vesik is one of 2 Estonian-Canadian graduate students who received a 2020 EFC Scholarship wit...
Grete Mugu was born in Tõrva in southern Eesti. At the age of 19 she moved to Germany in order...
When everyone found themselves at home without the usual activities, the Estonian Foundation of Can...
Selleks ongi Jumala Poeg saanud avalikuks, et Ta tühistaks kuradi teod. 1Jh 3:8bMe oleme elamas kat...
The Co-vid 19 virus has wreaked havoc and has reached all corners of our world, but with every cata...
Sini-must-valge värvikombinatsiooni idee sünd leidis aset 29. septembril 1881. aastal Tartus, ,,Vir...
Tänavu saab Eesti Vabariigi 103. aastapäeval tõmmata uisud jalga ja lasta koeral end tõmmata mööda ...
Wednesday, March 10th, 2021 at 7:00 PMAdmission begins at 6:00 PMTo be held electronically via Zoom...
Such an appropriate phrase for our troubled and confusing times. It was coined by the poet and soci...
BLINDSIDE James Patterson ja James O. Born. 2021, pehme köide Maailmakuulsate kirjanike James Patt...
Connor Olev O'Brien is CEO of O’Shares ETF Investments, as well as Stanton Asset Management. He has...
Helmi Hess on üks kahest Kanada Eesti teaduskraadi üliõpilasest, kes sai 2020. aasta ESK stipendium...
Kui Raivo ja Anne-Mari Remmel mõtlevad järgmise põlvkonna eestlastele, siis näevad nad tulevikus ...
Juhul, kui tekkiski kahtlus, eestlased on tõesti loov rahvas. Ajal, mil Covidi tõttu olid kõik oma ...
Niagara Falls – Eestlaste Kesknõukogu Kanadas (EKN) on organiseerinud Niagara kose rahvusvärvidegak...
The Estonian Central Council in Canada has organized the lighting of Niagara Falls in blue, black a...
Vabariigi aastapäev liidab meid rõõmus ja mures. Ta liidab meid ühise mineviku meenutustega ja tule...
Eestlaste Kesknõukogu Kanadas nimel soovin kõigile eestlastele Kanadas ja mujal ning meie toetajate...
Meenutame Laupäeval, 24. veebruaril 2018.a Torontos Nathan Phillips Square’il EV100 auks toimunud p...
To our dear friends in the Estonian Community,Palju õnne sünnipäevaks, Eesti!Best wishes on Estonia...
EV 103.a. virtuaalne tähistamine pühapäeval, 21. veebruaril Käesoleval aastal meie ei saa koos heis...
Talvel on linde lihtsam fotodele tabada kuna puud on raagus ja lehti ei ole millede varju linnud pe...
Praegusel pandeemia ajal tasub meeles pidada rahvatarkust ,,elu on võitlus, mida võitlema peab“, et...
Kaili Vesik is one of 2 Estonian-Canadian graduate students who received a 2020 EFC Scholarship wit...
When everyone found themselves at home without the usual activities, the Estonian Foundation of Can...
The Co-vid 19 virus has wreaked havoc and has reached all corners of our world, but with every cata...
Wednesday, March 10th, 2021 at 7:00 PMAdmission begins at 6:00 PMTo be held electronically via Zoom...
Kolmapäeval, 10. märtsil 2021 kell 19.00Osalejad võivad liituda alates kell 18.00Toimub elektroonil...
Briti Kolumbias, Vancouveri lähedal White Rock’is elav Annaliisa Kapp on holistiline toitu...
Mida ütleks vanaema, kui näeks pirukate valikus sõna KIMCHI? Arvan, et ta ütles: „Aga see ...
Armastus käib kõhu kaudu. Rahvatarkus. Luuletaja Hando Runnel lisas lausele vallatult, „le...
Estonia’s recently published annual Foreign Intelligence Service report focuses on the agg...
Eestlased läbi aja on olnud ohustatud liik. Neid on vähe ja neid on raske leida (samas on ...
Six years after Russian opposition leader Boris Nemtsov was assassinated, Ottawa has made ...
The world has followed closely the attempted assassination via poisoning, recent arrest, a...
Hiina valitsuse rahastatud suured taristuprojektid võivad tunduda ligitõmbavad, kuid nende...
The allure of doing business with one of the world’s largest economies is massive. Chinese...
''Enjoy the first online concert in Estonian Music Week's series ''Memories of Home'' feat...
Kes meist mäletab Metro rahvusvahelist Karavani? See oli siis, kui eestlased hakkasid kohe...
Hearing things about Estonia in English language films, TV shows, music, and books is an i...
At the Art Gallery of Nova Scotia, in Halifax, to visit the transplanted house and paintin...
Pühapäev on saanud oma nimetuse ladinakeelsest antiphonist.Algselt missa liturgia algusosa...
Toronto eesti kooli tunnis on päev enne Eesti Vabariigi sünnipäeva olulisteks sõnadeks rah...
24. veebruaril kutsus Tallinna Linna/muuseum tähistama Eesti Vaba/riigi 103. aasta/päeva v...
It's a commonly referenced fact that the Estonian language belongs to a different language...
Estonia kontserdisaalis oli 12. veebruaril kultuurilooliselt äärmiselt põnev kontsert, mid...
Kommentaarid
Please describe how the Russians influenced American voters in the 2016 Presidential elections.
And why no mention of Barack Obama's interference in last week's Canadian election?
Review: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/10/01/how-russia-helped-to-swing-the-election-for-trump
As has been previously 'revealed', the summary of Russian involvement was twitter posts and facebook ads and comments.
Kathleen Hall Jamieson, (hired by the Washington Post to uncover the Russian impact on the election), believed [Russian impact] had been misguidedly framed around the question of whether the Russians had “changed votes directly.” There wasn’t evidence for this. Instead, she suspected, the Russians had “influenced who voted, or didn’t vote, and that could have changed the outcome.”
What Kathleen Hall Jamieson doesn't analyze is, how did the Clinton and Obama BENGHAZI debacle of abandoning an American ambassador and staff, and the procuring and sending Libyan arms to ISIS, impact the election.?
https://www.nationalreview.com/2016/06/hillary-clinton-benghazi-scandal-how-she-survived/
Selle postituse kommentaaride RSS uudisvoog